Key Takeaways
- In a reverse auction, the buyer seeks to purchase a product or service and potential suppliers bid to offer the lowest price they are willing to accept.
- Reverse auctions can bring buyers cost savings and many other, less immediately-tangible benefits.
- Reverse auctions are an important tool that can help procurement with its digital transformation efforts.
It’s barely three months into 2023, and we’ve already seen scores of layoffs, media outlets promising an impending recession, and companies placing even more severe cost-savings burdens on their procurement departments. It’s a tough landscape to navigate.
That’s where reverse auctions come in. In light of 2023’s latest challenges, we wanted to highlight reverse auctions as an example of how investing in digital transformation can help procurement weather some of the challenges it’s facing.
A reverse auction differs from a traditional format in that the party running the auction is looking to buy a product or service instead of selling. As the phrase suggests, it reverses the roles of buyer and seller. In a reverse auction, the buyer dictates what goods or services are needed and asks vendors to bid against each other to win business. As suppliers compete with each other for the contract, in many cases it can result in better-quality goods or services at lower prices.
Reverse auctions can be hosted on e-procurement platforms, which helps automate the process and reduces the need for human intervention. That alone makes it an important solution as procurement faces layoffs and time crunches heading into 2023 and beyond.
What are the different types of reverse auctions?
There are two primary types of reverse auctions: Dutch and Japanese.
In a Dutch reverse auction, a low initial price is set for the good or service in question. The auction manager then increases the price by a predetermined amount until a seller accepts the bid and agrees to provide the goods or services at that price.
A Japanese reverse auction differs in that a high initial price is set which is then decreased by a predetermined amount. Once the price is decreased, sellers are asked whether they would like to accept that price or withdraw. This continues until only one seller is left. The seller remaining wins the bid and must supply the good or service at that price.
How much can you save with reverse auctions?
Reverse auctions bring about “hard-dollar” cost savings by increasing competition. Studies have shown that savings from reverse auctions can range from 11.0% to over 23.0%.
In a study done for the IBM Center for The Business of Government, David C. Wyld found that cost savings from reverse auctions for the US Department of State from the 2007 to 2010 fiscal years amounted to 11.0%.
Similarly, a study by the University of Arkansas Information Technology Research Institute found that reverse auctions generated net savings of 15.0% for buyers.
The General Services Administration (GSA) also reported that federal agencies using reverse auctions netted savings of 19.0% in the 2013 fiscal year and over 23.0% in the 2014 fiscal year.
What are some of the other benefits of reverse auctions?
Reverse auctions also bring about “soft-dollar” savings in the form of improvements to the procurement process which are important but more difficult to quantify.
First, reverse auctions speed up the sourcing process. Between offers and counteroffers, negotiating individually with suppliers involves a lot of back-and-forth, which can take several weeks; a reverse auction can compress this cycle into a few hours.
Second, reverse auctions offer increased transparency and enhanced compliance. Reverse auction software is highly structured and limits opportunities for corruption. For example, the bidder’s identity may be concealed until the offer is accepted. Furthermore, reverse auction software allows both internal and external stakeholders to see how the process unfolded and why a particular bidder won.
Reverse auctions also can help automate the procurement process, which means less administrative work for procurement professionals. This boosts productivity by freeing up your task list to work on higher-value tasks instead of routine paperwork.
The federal government found that reverse auctions increase small business participation. This can help buyers who want to increase the number of goods and services sourced from small businesses.
What are the drawbacks of reverse auctions?
The main drawback of reverse auctions is their focus on the purchase price at the expense of other considerations that go into goods and services. Quality may be sacrificed in the name of cost, and the auction may be won by a supplier that charges a low price but supplies substandard goods. Furthermore, a supplier could charge a very low purchase price to win the auction but more than make up for the lower price by charging high shipping and handling fees.
Another drawback of reverse auctions is that they are only suitable for a limited selection of goods.
What goods should be purchased using reverse auctions?
Chapter 5A of the West Virginia Code specifies the types of goods that should be purchased using reverse auctions. There are certainly other kinds of goods that could be made to fit this format, but we believe this list encompasses a good “best-practices” use case.
According to this code, goods purchased using reverse auctions should:
- Have a low level of price volatility
- Be sold by a large and competitive group of suppliers
- Be purchased mainly based on price
- Have simple specifications
- Have little variance between suppliers
- Require a low level of collaboration with the supplier
How should you incorporate reverse auctions into your digital transformation playbook?
Reverse auctions can be a valuable tool for procurement departments looking to streamline their purchasing processes and obtain the best possible prices for goods and services. To incorporate reverse auctions into your digital transformation playbooks, consider following these steps:
- Identify the appropriate goods and services that are suitable for reverse auctions.
- Select the right e-procurement and technology platform.
- Establish and train your staff on best practices for conducting reverse auctions, such as setting clear rules for bidding, monitoring bidding activity, and evaluating bids.
- Identify potential suppliers and invite them to participate in the reverse auction through an RFP process or by contacting suppliers directly.
Cost-saving measures such as reverse auctions may grow amid concerns that the United States is headed toward a recession. You can learn more about e-procurement by reading ProcurementIQ’s core report on procurement software or by visiting our blog.
Interested in more information on the best reverse auction platforms? Let’s get you started with some custom research.
Follow ProcurementIQ on LinkedIn to get notified of the latest procurement news and market developments from our experts to yours.
